A crit is a structured conversation about your work in progress. Prepare a short, clear introduction, listen more than you defend, and turn the feedback into a plan.
In short
- Prepare a two to three-minute introduction: the brief, your idea, key decisions, and one or two questions you want feedback on.
- Listen, take notes (or ask a classmate to), and ask clarifying questions instead of defending every choice.
- Afterwards, sort the feedback, decide what to act on, and record what you changed.
In this guide · 17 sections
- What a crit is
- Common crit formats
- Before the crit
- During the crit
- After the crit
- Dealing with difficult feedback
- Different kinds of feedback
- Online crits
- Preparing for assessment crits
- Peer feedback forms
- Building confidence over time
- Preparing your display
- Responding to common crit questions
- Crits with visiting professionals
- Learning from other people’s crits
- Common mistakes
- Frequently asked questions
What a crit is
A crit (short for critique) is a group or one-to-one session where tutors, peers and sometimes visiting practitioners discuss your work. Crits are a central part of art and design education. They can be formative (feedback to improve work in progress) or summative (part of assessment), and formats vary a lot between courses.
Kent State University’s teaching guidance describes the goal of a crit as improving the work, a “testing ground for ideas”, with formative feedback that guides how the student moves the work forward. Many students find crits stressful, especially at first. Preparation helps.
Common crit formats
| Format | What happens |
|---|---|
| Group crit | You present to the class and tutors; everyone comments |
| Tutor-led one-to-one | A conversation with a tutor about your work |
| Peer crit | Small groups give each other feedback, sometimes with written forms |
| Silent or written crit | People move around the work leaving written comments |
| Industry crit | A visiting designer or practitioner gives feedback |
California College of the Arts’ teaching guidance notes that long, oral-only crits can disadvantage language learners and students with auditory processing difficulties, attention difficulties or social anxiety, and suggests formats like written feedback. If a format is hard for you, talk to your tutor or student support in advance.
Before the crit
Set up your work
- Display clearly: pin up boards, lay out sketchbook pages, put garments on forms or hangers, or prepare slides.
- Show process: include research and development, not just the latest piece.
- Label things if helpful.
- Arrive early to set up.
Prepare a short introduction
Two to three minutes is usually enough:
- The brief in one sentence.
- Your idea or concept in one or two sentences.
- Where you are now: what’s finished, what’s in progress.
- Key decisions and why you made them.
- One or two specific questions you want feedback on.
Template: crit introduction
“My brief was to design a capsule of four looks for [customer/occasion]. My concept is [one sentence]. I started by researching [source], which led me to [key idea]. So far I’ve developed [what you have], and I’ve decided [key decision] because [reason]. I’m unsure about [specific question], and I’d especially like feedback on [area].”
Asking specific questions makes feedback more useful. “Does the colour palette feel too cold for the customer?” will get you more than “What do you think?”
During the crit
Listen first
- Let people finish. Don’t jump in to defend every point.
- Take notes, or ask a classmate to note feedback while you listen. UAL’s guidance for one crit preparation suggests sharing the note-taking load because it’s hard to listen, respond and take notes at once.
- Ask clarifying questions: “Can you say more about what feels unresolved?” “Which look do you mean?”
- Notice patterns: if three people mention the same thing, it matters.
Explain, don’t argue
It’s fine to explain your reasoning, briefly. But a crit isn’t a debate to win. The aim is to understand how your work is read by others.
Give good feedback to others
You’ll learn as much from giving feedback as receiving it. Rhode Island School of Design’s guide to critique suggests asking follow-up questions, especially when feedback seems subjective, and guiding conversation towards elements that haven’t been discussed. When you comment:
- Be specific: point to particular pieces, details or decisions.
- Describe before judging: “The jacket’s shoulder is very structured, while the trousers are soft” before “The look doesn’t work.”
- Suggest, don’t prescribe: “Have you tried…?” rather than “You should…”
- Be kind and honest. Both matter.
After the crit
Sort the feedback
Within a day, while it’s fresh, go through your notes and group feedback into:
- Act on: points you agree with or that came up repeatedly.
- Test: ideas worth trying before deciding.
- Consider and park: points you disagree with, with your reasons.
- Questions: things to clarify with your tutor.
Make a plan
Write two or three concrete next steps with dates. Record them in your sketchbook, along with what you change and why. This shows development and reflection, which many courses assess.
Worked example: turning feedback into actions
An invented example.
Feedback received:
- Three people said the colour palette felt “flat”.
- Tutor: research is strong, but it doesn’t show yet in the silhouettes.
- One peer: loved the knit swatches; wants to see them on the body.
Action plan:
- Test two accent colours from the original research photos (by Friday).
- Develop five new silhouettes directly from the research shapes (by next Tuesday).
- Make a knit sample sleeve and photograph it on a model (by next Thursday).
Parked: a suggestion to change the customer, because the brief fixes it; note for discussion with tutor.
Dealing with difficult feedback
- Separate the work from yourself. Feedback is about the work in progress, not your worth.
- Give yourself time before reacting.
- Ask for clarification if feedback is vague or harsh.
- Talk to someone you trust: a tutor, peer or student support.
- Notice what’s useful, even in feedback delivered badly.
If feedback ever feels discriminatory or inappropriate, raise it with your course leader or student support.
Different kinds of feedback
It helps to recognise the kind of feedback you’re receiving:
| Type | Example | How to use it |
|---|---|---|
| Descriptive | “The palette reads as very cold.” | Tells you how others see the work |
| Evaluative | “The second look is the strongest.” | Points to what’s working |
| Suggestive | “Have you tried a heavier fabric?” | An idea to test |
| Questioning | “Who is this for?” | Reveals gaps in your explanation or concept |
| Directive | “You need more development pages.” | Often linked to assessment criteria; take seriously |
Directive feedback from tutors, especially when linked to marking criteria, usually needs action. Suggestions from peers are worth considering and testing.
Online crits
Many crits now happen online or in hybrid form. To make them work:
- Prepare a short slide deck with clear images of your work and process.
- Test your audio, camera and screen sharing beforehand.
- Photograph physical work well, including details.
- Use the chat to share links or ask quick questions.
- Record the session only if everyone agrees and your course allows it.
Preparing for assessment crits
When a crit is part of assessment:
- Read the marking criteria and make sure your presentation addresses them.
- Show process and reflection, not just outcomes.
- Practise your introduction with a timer.
- Prepare for likely questions: “Why this?”, “What would you change?”, “Who is it for?”
- Bring everything required: sketchbooks, technical files, samples, final pieces.
Peer feedback forms
If your course uses written feedback forms, a simple structure helps everyone:
Template: peer feedback form
Project: [name]
One thing that works well, and why:
One question I have:
One suggestion to try:
Anything unclear?
Building confidence over time
Crits get easier with practice. Keep a short log after each one: what went well, what you’d do differently next time, and one thing you learned about presenting. Over a year, you’ll see real progress.
Preparing your display
How you display work affects how it’s read:
- Order it so viewers follow your journey: research on the left, development in the middle, outcome on the right.
- Show your best process pages rather than every page.
- Use labels if the connections aren’t obvious.
- Put garments on forms or models where possible, so people can see fit and drape.
- Light it well, especially for photographs and textiles.
Responding to common crit questions
| Question | How to respond |
|---|---|
| “Who is this for?” | Describe your customer or audience specifically |
| “Why did you choose this?” | Link to your research and concept |
| “What’s next?” | Give two or three concrete next steps |
| “What’s the most successful part?” | Name it and explain why |
| “What isn’t working yet?” | Be honest; show you’ve noticed |
| “Have you looked at [designer/artist]?” | Note it, thank them, and research it afterwards |
Crits with visiting professionals
Industry visitors bring a different perspective, often more commercial or practical. To make the most of it:
- research the visitor beforehand
- ask questions linked to their expertise
- note any industry-specific feedback (pricing, production, customer)
- thank them, and consider connecting on LinkedIn afterwards
Learning from other people’s crits
You’ll learn a lot from listening to feedback on classmates’ work. Notice:
- recurring feedback themes across the group
- how others present and respond
- techniques or references you could explore
- ways of explaining work clearly
Keep notes in your sketchbook.
Common mistakes
- Turning up without your process work.
- A long, unfocused introduction.
- Defending every point instead of listening.
- Not taking notes.
- Not asking specific questions.
- Ignoring feedback, or trying to act on all of it at once.
- Not recording what you changed.
Checklist
- My work, including process, is displayed clearly.
- I’ve prepared a two to three-minute introduction.
- I have one or two specific questions to ask.
- Someone is taking notes, or I’ve planned how to record feedback.
- I listened, asked clarifying questions and didn’t argue.
- I sorted feedback into act on, test, park and questions.
- I’ve written two or three concrete next steps with dates.
- I’ve recorded changes and reasons in my sketchbook.
Frequently asked questions
What if I don’t agree with the feedback?
That’s allowed. Consider it seriously, test it if possible, and if you still disagree, note your reasons. Be ready to explain your decision later.
What if no one says anything?
Ask your specific questions directly, or ask people what they noticed first.
Should I record the crit?
Only with everyone’s permission, and follow your course’s rules.
How to cite this guide
APA 7Shreya S. (2026, November 17). How to Present Your Work at a Crit (and Use the Feedback). Ayerhs Magazine. https://ayerhsmagazine.com/learn/guides/present-your-work-at-a-crit/MLA 9Shreya S. "How to Present Your Work at a Crit (and Use the Feedback)." Ayerhs Magazine, 17 Nov. 2026, ayerhsmagazine.com/learn/guides/present-your-work-at-a-crit/.Harvard (check your university’s version)Shreya S. (2026) How to Present Your Work at a Crit (and Use the Feedback). Ayerhs Magazine. Available at: https://ayerhsmagazine.com/learn/guides/present-your-work-at-a-crit/ (Accessed: [date you read it]).
Related on Ayerhs: How to keep a fashion sketchbook · How to build a fashion portfolio
Sources. Checked 17 November 2026. Formats and policies change, so always follow your own course handbook and tutor first.
- Kent State University Center for Teaching and Learning. “Critiques”. kent.edu
- California College of the Arts, Teaching Lab. “Equitable critiques”. portal.cca.edu
- Rhode Island School of Design, Arts & Language. “Introduction to Critique”. artsandlanguage.risd.edu
- University of the Arts London. “Preparing for your Unit 2 crit” (PDF). myblog.arts.ac.uk
- Emily Carr University of Art + Design. “What to know before your first critique” (2025). ecuad.ca
- Blair, B., Blythman, M. and Orr, S. Critiquing the Crit: Student Guide. academia.edu
- Elkins, J. (2012). Art Critiques: A Guide (recommended in RISD’s critique guide).
- Buster, K. and Crawford, P. (2009). The Critique Handbook: The Art Student’s Sourcebook and Survival Guide (recommended in RISD’s critique guide).
← All guides · Learn

